The NFL is back! I started writing this annual post at the beginning of the summer but got sidetracked by writing about the NBA, trips, and other responsibilities, but I wanted to make sure to get it done before any of these rookie wide receivers play. It's a much deeper position than the running backs, but I'm not sure quite how much star power it will end up with.
As mentioned last year, the stats that I'm looking at come from years of following JJ Zachariason's work, including each of his prospect guides, and the statistical marks that he looks at. I also make note of players' physical traits more than he does, but athleticism tends to matter less at this position than for running backs or tight ends.
Yards per team pass attempt (YPTPA) and yards per route run (YPRR) are the key production markers to keep in mind since they help tell a better story of a player's stats than raw numbers due to the huge differences in offensive styles from school to school. I'm also looking at how old they were when they became contributors and the percentage of their team's receptions, receiving yards, and receiving touchdowns in games they participated in. On the athletic testing side, 40 yard dash, the subsequent height-adjusted speed score (HaSS), vertical jump, broad jump, 3-cone time, and the short shuttle are all under consideration for WRs. I'm more focused on getting an idea of how athletic these prospects may or may not be than whether they hit certain thresholds, though.
Once again, all measurements are from the NFL combine (ideally) or pro day results as listed in Dane Brugler's The Beast on The Athletic, and the stats are coming from Sports Reference and Pro Football Focus.
1. Jordyn Tyson - 1st round, 8th overall, 2nd WR drafted - Saints
Tyson was one of the more divisive figures of the 1st round with the perception of how high he'd go varying to a large degree during draft, but I'm a big fan. He didn't have as many college stops as his older brother Jaylon, who was an NBA 1st rounder two years ago, but Jordyn started first his career at Colorado, where he led a 1-11 team in receiving yards and touchdowns as a true freshman. He did that despite missing the final three games with a torn ACL, MCL, and PCL, and his pro-rated market shares of 27.57% and 50%, respectively, are excellent for an 18 year old, and he had a strong 2.79 YPRR.
Following the coaching change to Deion Sanders and reportedly not feeling wanted, Tyson was part of the massive roster overhaul and transferred to Arizona State, where he missed all but a handful of snaps in 2023 as his knee recovered. He came back stronger than ever as a redshirt sophomore to put up 75 catches for 1,101 yards, and 10 touchdowns in only 12 games, resulting in outstanding marks of 3.48 YPTPA, 3.04 YPRR, a 38.27% reception share, 40.81% yardage share, and 45.45% TD share.
Nagging hamstring strains to both legs limited Tyson this past season to drop those figures to 2.19, 2.37, 37.58%, 34.50%, and 72.73%, but those are all still better than a lot of his peers. His early breakout, best-season market shares, and even a career 2.71 YPRR combine for an elite production profile, and he was only 21.69 years old on draft day.
Although Tyson wasn't healthy enough to participate in testing at the combine or a pro day, he was able to put on a private workout for teams before the draft to show his recovery from the hamstrings. He did join the measurements portion of the combine to confirm his 6'2.125" and 203 pound frame that allows him to play either outside or in the slot, and he makes the most out of that catch radius with good hands. Because he can get open with craft in addition to winning at the catch point with acrobatic grabs, Brugler even gave a Stefon Diggs comp.
Tyson was selected much higher in the draft than Diggs with the scary injury history not enough to prevent him from going in the top-10, and New Orleans is a really nice landing spot. Kellen Moore is a great offensive mind whose teams always tend to run a lot of plays thanks to a fast pace, and Tyler Shough improved at a nice rate as the second half of the season went on. The rookie will unfortunately start the season on IR with more hamstring issues, but whenever he makes his debut, he has a wide open opportunity to immediately become the #2 WR next to Chris Olave. While the Saints like Devaugn Vele (after surprisingly trading a 4th and 7th for him) and fellow rookie Bryce Lance also brings upside to the WR room, Tyson has the talent and runway to make an early impact just like he did in college.
2. Carnell Tate - 1st round, 4th overall, 1st WR drafted - Titans
While I think that Tyson will have the biggest impact on a per game basis, you can definitely make the case that Tate will have the best season-long stats as a rookie. Although it was a surprise just how high he went in the NFL draft, he was generally accepted to be the first WR selected thanks to having a pretty safe overall profile. As a sophomore, Tate was a contributor to Ohio State's 2024 national championship team playing alongside 1st rounder Emeka Egbuka and Jeremiah Smith, a likely top-5 pick in next year's draft, and then he truly broke out as a 20 year old junior.
Tate's overall totals don't jump off the page due to missing three games, but in the contests that he played his 2.74 YPTPA, 3.03 YPRR, 28.61% yardage share, and 31.03% touchdown share were all strong marks. He can get a bit of a pass on the 20.73% reception share due to working more down the field with 17.2 yard per catch and playing next to a generational prospect like Smith. For Tate's three-year career, he averaged 2.27 YPRR, which is more than acceptable, especially for an early declare prospect.
Already holding high draft stock, Tate didn't do a full workout at the combine but showed that he has the prototypical physical tools of an outside receiver by running a solid 4.53 40 yard dash at 6'2.25" and 192 pounds. His 6'6" wingspan also doesn't hurt with the 50/50 balls that he comes away with down the field. Joining a Titans team that signed the 5'8" Wan'Dale Robinson to be the top target competition, the rookie is expected to have a prominent role. 31 year old Calvin Ridley is coming off of a broken leg, and while Elic Ayomanor and Chimere Dike showed some nice flashes as rookies, Tate earned way higher draft capital for a reason. The main question is how much of a leap will last year's #1 overall pick Cam Ward make with a new coaching staff.
3. Makai Lemon - 1st round, 20th overall, 3rd WR drafted - Eagles (traded up)
Lemon is an interesting case after he was expected to go in the top half of the 1st round before the Eagles eventually moved up to stop his fall. He had a 2.05 YPRR in a very limited role as a freshman before posting an elite 3.03 rate as a sophomore despite an uneven offense. Lemon only averaged 1.75 YPTPA that year with 23.85% of the team's receiving yards his only notable market share number. Things came together in a big way this past year, though, as he posted a 2.96 YPTPA, 3.13 YPRR, a 30.15% reception share, 32.4% yardage share, and 44% TD share.
Having a birthday in June of 2004, Lemon is on the older side for his year (he's actually older than Tyson despite being a grade below him) to make that a 21 year old breakout as a junior, but those are still elite numbers, as is his 3.02 career YPRR. At 5'11.125", 192 pounds and wearing a single digit number at USC, it's easy to make a a comparison to Amon-Ra St. Brown (5'11.5" and 197 pounds at his combine) like Daniel Jeremiah did. Lemon's 4.50 40 at his pro day isn't going to blow anyone away but is adequate enough, especially for the type of receiver he is with his quickness and versatility to work out of the slot.
Landing in Philadelphia should provide a nice opportunity immediately with the departure of AJ Brown. Lemon missed a good amount of the offseason with hamstring issues, so he might start the season as the #3 receiver but could easily finish as the #2 behind DeVonta Smith by the end of the season. Trade acquisition Dontayvion Wicks has been productive in a limited role, so we'll see if provides tough competition throughout the season. They made the move up to draft Lemon for a reason, though, and his type of talent should show itself sooner rather than later.